Iowa Workers' Compensation for Shoulder Injuries: Treatment, Benefits, and Fair Compensation

When you hurt your shoulder at work, the physical pain is only the beginning. Understanding your shoulder injury, getting proper medical care, and securing fair compensation can be overwhelming. Especially when dealing with insurance companies that put profits over your recovery.

Hundreds of Iowa workers sustain work-related shoulder injuries every year. If you work in construction, manufacturing, warehousing, or other physical jobs, a shoulder injury can prevent you from working and earning a living. The good news? Iowa workers' compensation laws provide benefits to cover your medical expenses, replace lost wages, and compensate you for permanent impairment.

This guide explains the most common types of shoulder work injuries, available treatment options, how compensation is calculated, and why that initial settlement offer from the insurance company is probably far less than what you deserve.

Common Types of Shoulder Injuries at Work

Knowing the specific type of shoulder injury you sustained is critical for receiving proper treatment and maximizing your workers' compensation benefits. Not all shoulder injuries are the same, and each type comes with distinct symptoms, treatment protocols, and compensation implications.

Rotator Cuff Injuries

A rotator cuff injury involves damage to the group of muscles and tendons surrounding the shoulder joint. Unlike many acute injuries that occur from a single traumatic event, rotator cuff injuries typically develop over time. This is through tendon degeneration caused by repetitive overhead motions or extended periods lifting heavy materials.

Common symptoms of rotator cuff injuries include:

Pain that worsens with movement
Significant loss of mobility and range of motion
Arm weakness that makes routine tasks difficult
Pain that disrupts sleep, especially when lying on the affected shoulder

Warehouse and construction workers face a higher risk of rotator cuff injuries due to the repetitive nature of their job. If your work involves regular overhead reaching, lifting heavy objects, or sustained arm elevation, you may be at increased risk for rotator cuff injuries.

This gradual onset does not take away your right to workers' compensation benefits. If your job duties caused or greatly added to the condition, you qualify for coverage.

Frozen Shoulder Syndrome

Frozen shoulder syndrome represents one of the most challenging and frustrating shoulder injuries workers can experience. This condition causes major loss of range of motion in the shoulder, essentially "freezing" the joint and limiting your ability to perform basic tasks.

Frozen shoulder can develop in two primary ways after a work-related shoulder injury. First, it may occur when your arm is in a sling during recovery from another shoulder injury. The immobilization contributes to joint stiffness. Second, it can develop directly from the shoulder injury itself as scar tissue forms around the joint.

The limited treatment options available make frozen shoulder particularly difficult to manage. Physical therapy remains the primary treatment approach, typically requiring both supervised sessions and home exercises to gradually restore mobility. When physical therapy proves insufficient, doctors may recommend manipulation under anesthesia, a procedure where the physician physically stretches and moves your shoulder under anesthesia. The pain following this procedure can be severe, and results vary significantly between patients.

Regardless of treatment, frozen shoulder that does not improve often results in permanent restrictions and entitlement to permanent workers' compensation benefits based on lasting range of motion limitations.

Shoulder Impingement Syndrome

Shoulder impingement syndrome happens when the bone on the top of your shoulder rubs against, or impinges, the tendon and bursa in the shoulder. This repetitive friction causes inflammation, pain, and progressive damage to the soft tissues.

According to the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, shoulder impingement frequently results from repetitive lifting or performing overhead activities, movements that are standard in construction and painting industries. The condition is closely related to rotator cuff tendinitis and bursitis.

Symptoms of shoulder impingement include:

Pain when lifting objects or reaching overhead
Discomfort during common work duties
Progressive worsening of symptoms with continued activity
Limited range of motion as inflammation increases

Initial treatment typically involves anti-inflammatory medications to reduce pain and swelling. However, for these medications to work effectively, you have to avoid the activities that caused the inflammation, which often means being unable to perform your regular job duties. Physical therapy may be prescribed to strengthen surrounding muscles and improve shoulder mechanics. Doctors may recommend steroid injections if conservative treatments prove unsuccessful.

When nonsurgical treatment fails to resolve shoulder impingement, surgery becomes necessary. Surgical treatment increases the space available for the rotator cuff by removing the inflamed bursa and sometimes part of the top bone of the shoulder. Recovery time depends on whether your surgeon uses arthroscopic techniques with smaller incisions or open surgery requiring larger incisions.

Fractured Clavicle and Other Traumatic Injuries

Unlike the gradually developing conditions described above, some shoulder injuries result from acute traumatic events. Fractured clavicles, dislocated shoulders, and severe soft tissue damage often occur during workplace falls, equipment accidents, or when workers are struck by falling objects.

For breaks and fractures, surgery is frequently required. The shoulder will typically be set in a cast or sling for approximately one month while initial healing occurs. Ice therapy helps reduce swelling and inflammation, while prescription pain relievers manage the often-severe pain associated with these injuries.

Depending on the severity and healing progress, some workers develop post-traumatic arthritis in the shoulder joint. This occurs when broken bone fragments rub against cartilage, causing chronic inflammation, swelling, and debilitating pain. In the most severe cases, workers may require total shoulder replacement surgery to restore function and reduce pain.

Treatment Options for Shoulder Work Injuries

The goal of all treatment for shoulder injuries at work is to manage pain and help the shoulder regain normal mobility. Treatment methods differ greatly depending on your injury's type and severity. They can range from simple, non-invasive options to more complex surgeries.

Conservative Treatment Approaches

Most shoulder work injuries begin with conservative treatment methods:

Rest and Activity Modification: Avoiding movements that worsen symptoms is essential for healing. This often means you cannot perform your regular job duties during recovery.

Ice Therapy: Applied to bring down swelling and inflammation, particularly important in the first days and weeks following injury.

Pain Management: Strong prescription pain relievers may be necessary for shoulder injuries, which can be extremely painful and disrupt sleep.

Physical Therapy: Prescribed to improve shoulder function, strengthen surrounding muscles, and restore range of motion. Success requires commitment to both supervised sessions and home exercises.

Anti-Inflammatory Medications: Help reduce pain and swelling, allowing other treatments to work more effectively.

Cortisone Injections: Injections into the shoulder muscle can reduce inflammation when oral medications prove insufficient.

Bracing and Immobilization: Some injuries require keeping the shoulder immobilized to allow proper healing, though prolonged immobilization carries the risk of frozen shoulder development.

Surgical Interventions

When conservative treatments fail to produce desired results, surgical intervention becomes necessary. Common surgical procedures for work-related shoulder injuries include:

Rotator Cuff Surgery: Repairs tears in the rotator cuff tendons, restoring strength and function to the shoulder.

Shoulder Decompression Surgery: Removes the bursa and part of the shoulder bone to create more space and reduce impingement.

Distal Clavicle Excision: Removes the end of the collarbone when it causes pain by rubbing against other shoulder structures.

Arthroscopic Procedures: Minimally invasive surgeries using small instruments and cameras, typically resulting in faster recovery than open surgery.

Total Shoulder Replacement: Reserved for severe cases where post-traumatic arthritis causes debilitating pain that cannot be managed through other treatments.

Following surgery, recovery requires diligent adherence to doctor's orders. This includes bed rest periods, keeping the shoulder immobilized as directed, taking prescribed medications, attending physical therapy sessions, and completing home exercises. Attempting to return to work before your doctor clears you can compromise your recovery and potentially worsen your injury.

Some shoulder injuries prevent workers from returning to work for weeks, months, or permanently. Even with successful treatment, you may never regain full shoulder function, particularly with severe injuries or frozen shoulder syndrome.

Understanding Workers' Compensation Benefits for Shoulder Injuries

Iowa workers' compensation provides multiple categories of benefits for employees who hurt their shoulder at work.

Medical Benefits Coverage

Workers' compensation insurance must cover all reasonable and necessary medical expenses related to your shoulder work injury, including:

Emergency room visits and hospital stays
Doctor appointments and specialist consultations
Diagnostic testing such as X-rays, MRIs, and CT scans
Physical therapy and rehabilitation services
Surgical procedures and related costs
Prescription medications and over-the-counter drugs
Medical devices including slings, braces, and assistive equipment
Follow-up care and ongoing treatment

Workers' compensation covers surgery to repair damage from a work injury because it represents medically necessary treatment for your recovery. However, if you elect to undergo experimental or elective procedures not recommended by your doctor, those treatments may not be covered.

Disability Benefits: More Than Just Lost Wages

When your shoulder injury prevents you from working or limits your earning capacity, you become eligible for disability benefits. Iowa law provides several types of disability compensation:

Temporary Total Disability (TTD) Benefits: Provides a portion of your pre-injury wages while you recuperate and cannot work at all. These benefits continue until you reach maximum medical improvement or can return to work.

Temporary Partial Disability Benefits: Available when you return to work at a lesser-paying position to accommodate your injury. These benefits help offset the difference between your previous earnings and current reduced wages.

Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) Benefits: Compensation for lasting impairment that permanently affects your ability to work, even after you reach maximum medical improvement.

Permanent Total Disability Benefits: In rare cases where shoulder injuries are so severe that you cannot return to any gainful employment, you may qualify for ongoing weekly payments for life.

How Shoulder Injury Compensation Is Actually Calculated

Here is where many injured workers get confused, and where insurance companies take advantage of that confusion to pay far less than workers deserve.

In Iowa, permanent compensation for shoulder injuries is based on 500 weeks of benefits. The critical question is: what percentage of industrial disability do you have?

This is not the same as your impairment rating.

Your doctor will evaluate you for an impairment rating using the AMA Guides. This rating, based primarily on your lack of range of motion, might be 5%, 10%, or even higher. Impairment ratings for shoulder injuries can range from zero to 50 percent of the whole person.

The insurance company will send you a letter explaining how much they paid for your time off work and how much they plan to pay based on your impairment rating. Many workers assume this represents their total entitlement and accept the payment.

This is often a costly mistake.

Your impairment rating is only one factor in determining your industrial disability percentage. Iowa law requires consideration of numerous additional factors when assessing the true value of your shoulder injury:

Permanent work restrictions: Far more important than your impairment rating. Restrictions placing you in sedentary or light work categories dramatically increase your industrial disability.
Type of medical care received: Rotator cuff surgery, distal clavicle excision, shoulder replacement, and other procedures indicate injury severity.
Educational level: Workers with limited formal education face greater challenges finding alternative employment.
Age: Older workers have more difficulty retraining for different careers.
Earnings and earnings history: Your pre-injury income affects the calculation.
Ability to return to your previous job: If you cannot perform your original work, your industrial disability increases significantly.
Loss of employment: Workers who lose their jobs due to injury restrictions receive higher compensation than those who return to the same employer.

For example, a doctor might assign you a 10% whole body impairment rating. However, given permanent restrictions placing you in light work categories, age, inability to return to your previous manufacturing job, a judge could determine you have 40% industrial disability.

Forty percent of 500 weeks equals 200 weeks of permanent partial disability benefits. If your weekly rate is $800, that is $160,000 in compensation, far more than the $40,000 the insurance company offered based solely on your 10% impairment rating.

This is why consulting with a qualified Iowa workers' compensation attorney before accepting any settlement is crucial.

Why Your Employer's Doctor May Not Be on Your Side

Iowa workers' compensation law grants your employer the authority to choose the medical provider who will treat your shoulder injury. This can create a conflict of interest that injured workers must navigate carefully.

Employer-chosen doctors may have conscious or unconscious bias toward the employer and insurance company. After all, the employer repeatedly refers injured workers to this doctor, creating an ongoing business relationship. This could cause:

Inadequate Treatment: The doctor may be reluctant to authorize expensive treatments like surgery, even when medically necessary.

Low Impairment Ratings: Ratings that underestimate the true extent of your permanent impairment protect the insurance company's financial interests.

Overly Optimistic Return-to-Work Assessments: Clearing you to return to work before you have fully healed or without appropriate restrictions.

Premature Maximum Medical Improvement Determinations: Declaring you have reached maximum recovery before exhausting reasonable treatment options.

If you believe the treatment you are receiving is inadequate, you have options. You can file a petition for alternate medical treatment with the Iowa Workers' Compensation Commissioner. This formal process allows you to request a different doctor if the current physician's care is insufficient.

Additionally, if you disagree with the impairment rating assigned by your employer's doctor, you can request a second examination by another physician. Iowa law requires this second examination to be performed at the employer's expense when properly requested.

An experienced workers' compensation attorney can guide you through these processes, helping you secure the treatment and fair evaluation you deserve.

Common Insurance Company Tactics to Minimize Your Claim

Insurance companies employ well-documented strategies to reduce the amount they pay on shoulder injury claims. Being aware of these tactics helps you protect your rights and interests.

The Impairment Rating Trap

Insurance companies frequently offer settlements based solely on impairment ratings, ignoring all other factors that contribute to industrial disability. They present these offers in official-looking letters that make it seem like this is the standard calculation, hoping injured workers will accept without question.

Remember: your impairment rating is just the starting point, not the final answer.

Denying Necessary Treatment

Insurance companies may refuse to authorize recommended surgical procedures, arguing that conservative treatment should be attempted first, even after conservative treatment has already failed. This tactic saves them immediate medical costs while potentially compromising your long-term recovery.

The Pre-Existing Condition Argument

If you had any prior shoulder problems, even minor ones, insurance companies will argue your current injury is simply a continuation of a pre-existing condition that should not be covered.

This argument fails to account for Iowa law's clear standard: if your work activities aggravated, accelerated, or worsened a pre-existing condition, you still qualify for full workers' compensation benefits.

Premature Settlement Pressure

Insurance adjusters may pressure you to settle your claim quickly, before you fully understand the extent of your injury or have reached MMI (maximum medical improvement). Once you settle and sign a release, you cannot reopen your claim if your shoulder fails to heal or worsens over time.

Never feel rushed into accepting a settlement. Take time to understand your options and consult with an attorney who can evaluate whether the offer fairly compensates you for all your losses.

Take Action to Protect Your Future

At attorney can help you to gather the documentation you need and will work to get you the benefits you deserve. If your claim has been denied or if you need help with the workers’ compensation claims filing process, don’t wait any longer to take action. At Walker, Billingsley & Bair, our attorneys are ready to work for you. To start fighting for your rights today, call our offices at (888) 435-9886 or contact us online.

What Preventative Measures You Can Take to Lower Chances of Shoulder Injuries at Work

Shoulder Decompression Surgery and Iowa Workers’ Compensation