Attorneys
- Independence Personal Injury Attorneys
- Phone: 641-792-3595
- Directions
Pedestrian Accidents and Iowa's Comparative Negligence Rule
When a pedestrian is struck by a car, many people assume the driver is automatically at fault and the pedestrian is automatically entitled to full compensation. Under Iowa law, the reality is more nuanced. Both parties in a pedestrian-car accident will be assigned a certain degree of fault for the incident. Attorneys, insurance companies, and courts will examine all the facts surrounding the accident to determine what percentage of responsibility belongs to each party. In some situations the fault lies clearly with one party; in others, both the pedestrian and the driver may share responsibility to varying degrees.
According to the National Highway Transportation Administration National Center for Statistics and Analysis, 68 percent of pedestrian accidents occur at night. This statistic matters legally because a pedestrian who fails to take safety precautions in low-visibility conditions, such as by not wearing reflective or light-colored clothing or not carrying a light, may be found partly negligent for the accident.
Pedestrian Behavior That Can Create Partial Liability
There are several specific behaviors that can result in a pedestrian bearing some share of fault in a car accident claim. These include failing to use a crosswalk, crossing a street on a "don't walk" signal, walking or running in front of traffic, not taking nighttime safety precautions such as wearing reflective clothing, and failing to obey other applicable traffic rules. When any of these factors are present, they become part of the fault analysis that determines how much compensation the pedestrian can ultimately recover.
How Iowa's Comparative Negligence Law Affects Your Recovery
Iowa follows the comparative negligence rule, which means that even if a person was partly responsible for their own accident, they can still seek compensation for their injuries, provided they were not more than 50 percent at fault. However, the settlement amount will be reduced proportionally to the individual's degree of fault.
To illustrate: a pedestrian walking down a dark street at night in dark clothing is struck by a car while crossing mid-block, not at a lit crosswalk. If a court or jury determines the pedestrian was 40 percent liable for the accident, the settlement award would be reduced by that same 40 percent. A $100,000 settlement would become $60,000. This is why proving liability in a pedestrian accident claim is critically important. The percentage of fault assigned directly determines how much compensation a victim receives.
When fault is blurry or disputed, injury victims should contact an attorney as soon as possible to begin collecting evidence and working to establish what actually happened. An attorney can uncover facts regarding the accident, protect the client's rights throughout the process, and work to lessen the client's assigned degree of fault. An attorney will also account for and calculate the full scope of damages and push for the highest and fairest possible settlement.
You Do Not Have to Accept the Insurance Company's Settlement Offer
One of the most important things any personal injury victim in Independence can understand is that accepting an insurance company's settlement offer is entirely voluntary. In Iowa, you are not required to accept any settlement offer that does not fairly reflect the value of your claim. That said, there are several important considerations to evaluate before deciding how to respond to an offer.
Three Questions to Answer Before Making Any Decision
First, consider whether your injuries are minor enough that handling the claim yourself, without paying an attorney a percentage of the settlement, makes financial sense. For very minor injuries with limited medical bills, self-representation may be appropriate. For anything more significant, the cost of legal representation is almost always offset by the higher recovery an attorney achieves.
Second, understand who will need to be reimbursed for medical bills that have already been paid. If your health insurance or another insurance policy covered your treatment, those insurers likely have subrogation rights requiring reimbursement from any settlement proceeds. Failing to address subrogation properly can cost a victim their entire settlement. This is one of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of personal injury claims, and getting it wrong has severe consequences.
Third, know how much time remains before the statute of limitations expires. Once that deadline passes, the right to seek any compensation at all is typically lost. If you are uncertain about any of these three questions, speaking with a qualified Iowa injury attorney before taking any action is strongly recommended.
The Insurance Company's First Offer Is Rarely Their Best Offer
It is very rare that an insurance company's first settlement offer reflects the true value of a claim. Attempting to negotiate when you are representing yourself is appropriate, but it must be done carefully. Anything you tell an insurance adjuster can and will be used against you in your claim, and potentially in a subsequent lawsuit. Honesty is essential; never lie to an adjuster, even when describing prior injuries or accidents, because insurance companies share databases and inconsistencies will surface. Prior injuries and accidents will be discovered regardless.
It is also not productive to threaten an adjuster or become angry during negotiations. As with most difficult conversations, a calm, factual approach gets better results than an emotional one. Know the basic facts of your case: how the injuries happened, which providers treated you, and what conditions you have been diagnosed with. Being prepared and composed signals that you understand your claim and are not going to accept an inadequate offer simply because of pressure.
How to Evaluate the True Value of a Personal Injury Claim
Before agreeing to any settlement involving injuries, speaking with a qualified Iowa injury attorney provides an objective perspective from someone who deals with insurance companies daily and has handled hundreds of comparable cases. No two cases are identical, but they share common factors that determine value. The key elements that go into evaluating a personal injury claim's worth include the severity and extent of the injuries, whether multiple body parts were injured, whether objective injuries such as broken bones are present, whether hospitalization was required, whether surgery was necessary, how much time the victim missed from work, the context of where the injury occurred, the amount of available insurance coverage, and whether a claim for underinsured motorist coverage may be applicable. Understanding all of these factors together is how a realistic and defensible claim valuation is built.
What a Personal Injury Attorney Actually Does for Your Case in Independence
Many injury victims underestimate the scope of what a qualified attorney actually does on their behalf. Legal representation is not simply about having someone make phone calls or write letters. When a case is handled by an experienced Iowa personal injury attorney, the range of tasks performed on the client's behalf is extensive, and every one of those tasks is aimed at strengthening the claim and maximizing recovery. All of this work is performed at no upfront cost because Iowa personal injury attorneys are paid a percentage only when a case is successfully resolved.
Education, Investigation, and Evidence Collection
An attorney begins by educating the client about Iowa's injury laws, which vary from state to state and are far too complex for an untrained person to navigate confidently. From there, the attorney gathers documentary evidence including police accident reports, medical records, and bills. When necessary, investigators are hired to interview witnesses, locate additional witnesses who may not have been identified initially, and collect physical evidence such as photographs of vehicles and the accident scene.
The attorney reviews and analyzes the legal issues specific to the case, including comparative fault and assumption of the risk, two concepts that insurance companies regularly use to argue for reduced settlements. Understanding how these defenses apply in the client's situation allows the attorney to counter them effectively.
Medical Analysis, Physician Coordination, and Insurance Policy Review
A qualified attorney talks directly with the client's treating physicians and obtains written medical reports to support the case and fully establish the nature and extent of the injuries. Rather than simply sending letters and waiting, attorneys experienced in Iowa personal injury law know that in-person conversations with doctors produce stronger, more useful causation opinions that hold up to scrutiny.
The attorney also analyzes the client's insurance policy to identify any coverages that may pay for medical bills while the claim is still pending. Many injury victims are unaware of available coverage within their own policies that could provide immediate financial relief and increase overall recovery. This policy analysis ensures that no potential source of compensation goes unnoticed.
Lien Management, Settlement Preparation, and Trial Readiness
Doctors, insurance companies, welfare benefit plans, and employers may all assert liens claiming they are entitled to some portion of any recovery the client receives. An attorney reviews and analyzes the validity of every lien, challenges incorrect or excessive claims, and negotiates amounts owed. This lien management often results in significantly more money in the client's pocket from the same settlement total.
When the time comes to pursue resolution, the attorney prepares a comprehensive demand package and sends it to the defendant in an attempt to negotiate a fair settlement before trial. If mediation is scheduled, the attorney prepares for it. If the case proceeds to litigation, the attorney prepares the client, witnesses, and healthcare providers for depositions, takes the depositions of the defendant and other relevant witnesses, files all necessary motions and briefs with the court, and organizes medical and demonstrative exhibits for trial. Throughout the entire process, the attorney handles the legal complexity so the client can focus on physical recovery.
- Iowa's comparative negligence rule reduces a pedestrian's recovery by their percentage of fault; victims up to 50% at fault can still recover damages
- Nighttime pedestrian behavior like wearing dark clothing or crossing mid-block can increase your assigned fault percentage and reduce your compensation
- You are never required to accept an insurance company's settlement offer in Iowa
- Subrogation rights held by health insurers can consume an entire settlement if not properly managed by an attorney
- The insurance company's first offer is rarely their best offer; never threaten adjusters, and never lie, even about prior injuries
- Personal injury attorneys are paid a percentage only on success; all investigation, negotiation, and trial work is performed at no upfront cost
We Are Here To Help
Remember, you are not alone in recovering from your injuries. We have helped thousands of Iowans through their physical, emotional, and financial recoveries. If you have questions about what you are going through, feel free to call our office for your confidential injury conference. We will take the time to listen to you and give you our advice concerning your injury matter at no cost or risk to you.
Free Book at No Cost
If you are not ready to speak with an attorney yet but would like to learn more about Iowa injury cases including tips about how you can avoid making common costly mistakes request a copy of our Iowa Personal Injury book which includes 14 myths about Iowa injury cases and 5 things to know before hiring an attorney.
If you have specific questions about your injury matter feel free to call our office to speak with our Injury team at 641-792-3595 or use our Chat feature by clicking here 24 hours a day/7 days per week. Your information will remain confidential and there is no cost or obligation.