• Lake Mills Workers Compensation Attorneys
  • Phone: 641-792-3595
  • Directions

Getting hurt on the job is stressful enough without also having to navigate Iowa's workers' compensation system, deal with an insurance company that may not have your best interests in mind, or gather evidence to support a claim that is being disputed. Lake Mills workers who have suffered a shoulder injury, need help proving what happened on the job, or are facing a denied claim all deserve to understand their rights under Iowa law. Below is important information Lake Mills workers should know about the value of a shoulder injury claim, how coworker testimony can support a disputed claim, and what steps are available when a workers' compensation claim is denied.

How Much Is a Shoulder Injury Worth Under Iowa Work Comp Law?

Shoulder injuries are common in Lake Mills workplaces, and many injured workers want to know right away how much their claim might be worth. The honest answer is that it depends heavily on the facts of the individual case. A worker who has made a good recovery and returned to their regular job will generally have a claim worth far less than a worker who has permanent restrictions that their employer could not accommodate, resulting in job loss.

If a shoulder injury caused by work is permanent, compensation is based on 500 weeks of benefits under Iowa law. For example, if it is determined that a worker has 20 percent industrial disability, that worker should receive 100 weeks of permanent compensation, since 20 percent of 500 weeks equals 100 weeks. It is important to remember that an impairment rating is different from industrial disability. The weekly amount paid is the same rate the worker received for time missed from work. Permanent compensation is generally supposed to be paid in a lump sum, plus interest calculated back to the date the worker last received temporary total disability benefits, or back to the date of injury if the worker never missed work.

What Factors Affect a Lake Mills Shoulder Injury Claim?

A number of factors are considered when assessing permanent compensation, also called industrial disability, for a shoulder injury under Iowa's workers' compensation system, including:

  • Permanent impairment rating (a relatively low rating, such as 5 percent, should not necessarily be a source of concern, since it is generally based only on the lack of range of motion in the shoulder)
  • Permanent work restrictions, which are typically much more important than the impairment rating
  • The type of medical care received, such as rotator cuff surgery, distal clavicle excision, torn labrum surgery, total shoulder replacement, or steroid injections
  • Educational level
  • Age
  • Earnings
  • Earnings history over the past five years
  • Whether the worker has been able to return to the same job held at the time of injury

Insurance companies will often send an injured worker a letter setting out how much they have paid for time off work and how much they plan to pay for the impairment rating. Impairment ratings for shoulder injuries can range from 0 percent all the way up to 50 percent to the whole person. It is important to remember that the impairment rating is only one factor. A worker with a 10 percent rating but permanent restrictions that place them in a sedentary or light work category may actually have an industrial disability that is much higher than 10 percent. A worker can cash the checks an insurance company sends for an impairment rating, but before agreeing to any settlement, it is wise to consult with a qualified Iowa workers' compensation attorney to avoid accepting less than what is actually owed.

Can Coworkers Testify in a Lake Mills Workers' Compensation Claim?

When a Lake Mills worker is injured on the job and there is a dispute concerning the accident, coworkers can be asked to testify as part of a workers' compensation claim. There is a place on the First Report of Injury or Illness form where a worker can list a witness to the event that caused the injury. Understandably, some coworkers may worry about retaliation from the employer for providing a statement, so it is important that everyone involved understands their rights.

Why Coworkers May Hesitate to Testify

A coworker may hesitate to testify about a work accident out of fear of being fired, harassed, demoted, or subjected to some other form of retaliation. However, employees cannot get in trouble for sharing what they witnessed, particularly where the safety of other workers is at issue.

How Coworker Testimony Can Help a Claim

There are several reasons a Lake Mills worker might need a coworker's statement. One common situation arises when an employer or insurance carrier tries to argue that an injury was not work-related. If other employees witnessed what happened, their testimony can support the injured worker's account that the injury occurred on the job. For example, a coworker might testify to seeing someone fall off a ladder, or may know about a workplace hazard that caused an illness.

Coworker testimony can also help when there is a disagreement about the extent or severity of an injury. A treating physician might release an employee back to work before that employee is truly ready. If a doctor's notes describe only a minor bump on the head, but coworkers witnessed the employee lose consciousness, that testimony could point toward a more serious injury than initially recorded. Coworkers may also have access to helpful evidence such as photographs of the accident scene, which can help substantiate what actually caused the injury.

Disputes in a Lake Mills workers' compensation claim can vary widely, and when a dispute cannot be resolved, it may require a hearing where solid evidence is essential. An attorney can help an injured worker identify coworkers who may provide valuable testimony and can explain both an injured worker's rights and an employer's responsibilities, including the steps to take if there is concern about retaliation against a coworker who agrees to testify.

Can You Fight a Workers' Compensation Denial in Lake Mills?

Yes, Lake Mills workers can fight back if an insurer denies a workers' compensation claim and the worker disagrees with the decision. The first step in any dispute is to try to calmly and honestly resolve the disagreement directly with the employer or the employer's insurance company.

Requesting a Hearing With the Iowa Workers' Compensation Commissioner

If the worker and the insurance company cannot resolve the dispute on their own, the worker can request a hearing with the Iowa Workers' Compensation Commissioner. A Deputy Workers' Compensation Commissioner, who functions as an administrative law judge, will hear arguments from both sides and issue a ruling. The Deputy Commissioner examines the evidence in the case and may request arguments from attorneys. The injured worker may testify, and other witnesses may testify as well. Each party may submit a brief explaining its position, and the Deputy Commissioner ultimately rules based on the applicable administrative laws and codes.

A worker who is unsatisfied with the Deputy Commissioner's ruling can appeal to the Iowa Workers' Compensation Commissioner, who reviews the evidence and issues the agency's final decision. At this stage, parties may submit briefs but will generally not submit additional evidence. Many workers choose to hire an attorney for hearings before a Deputy Commissioner and for appeals to the Commissioner.

Appealing a Case Beyond the Iowa Workers' Compensation Commissioner

Workers who remain unsatisfied can pursue judicial review, where Iowa courts determine how the law was applied. These appeals can proceed through Iowa district courts, appellate courts, and even the Iowa Supreme Court. In rare instances, a case may be remanded for a new hearing or for consideration of additional evidence. Having an attorney during the judicial review process helps ensure the correct procedures are followed and that the case is properly argued after the Commissioner's final ruling.

Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Workers' Compensation Claims?

There are valid reasons an insurer may deny a workers' compensation claim, including a lack of evidence, a violation of law or policy, or expiration of the statute of limitations. If a worker was intoxicated or intentionally caused the injury, that may also give an insurer grounds to deny benefits. Unfortunately, insurance companies sometimes deny claims or reduce benefits without a valid reason, often in an effort to reduce what they must pay. They may attempt to blame an injury on a pre-existing condition or argue that an injury is not truly work-related, which can happen frequently with repetitive motion injuries that lack one single, obvious triggering event.

What Protections Do Lake Mills Workers Have?

Workers cannot be fired for pursuing a workers' compensation claim, and employers cannot punish other employees for supporting a coworker's claim. Employers also cannot consider a past workers' compensation claim as a factor when deciding whether to hire someone for a future position. Any Lake Mills worker who runs into these issues should speak with an attorney right away.

Getting Legal Assistance In Lake Mills

Navigating the complexities of Iowa workers' compensation laws can be daunting, especially during the recovery process from a workplace injury. Seeking guidance from a seasoned Lake Mills Workers' Comp attorney is invaluable in ensuring your rights are protected and maximizing your chances of a favorable outcome.

Legal professionals play a pivotal role in gathering evidence, preparing documentation, and advocating for your interests throughout the claims process. Don't risk missing out on the compensation you deserve – enlist the support of a qualified attorney to navigate the complexities with confidence.

The Iowa Workers' Compensation attorney team at Walker, Billingsley & Bair know the importance of protecting your work injury claim from the get-go. That's why we provide this FREE book; Iowa Workers' Compensation - An Insider's Guide to Work Injuries: 7 Deadly Mistakes To Avoid If You Are Hurt At Work. To learn more about what our legal team will do to help you protect your Iowa work injury claim, contact Walker, Billingsley & Bair to schedule a no-cost consultation - 641-792-3595.

More Info on Lake Mills Attorneys